简体中文

论著-头颈部

评估筛查性CT结肠成像的诊断差异临床研究

作者:俞红兵 姚 军

所属单位:上海市松江区中心医院(上海 201600)

PDF

摘要

目的探讨CT结肠成像诊断结肠 息肉中放射科医师评估诊断的差异。方 法 收集2013年4月-2015年3月期间我院检 查的120例高度怀疑为结肠息肉患者的CT 结肠影像,由4位不同水平的放射科医师 (不知道纤维结肠镜结果)分别在使用和 不使用辅助诊断工具(计算机辅助检测, Computer-Aided Detection,CAD)的情 况下进行阅片,以纤维结肠镜检查为金标 准,观察不同水平医师在不同情况下对结 肠息肉检出的敏感性、特异性、准确性、 阳性预测值和阴性预测值。结果 同水平 医师在相同诊断条件下对结肠息肉检出 情况比较差异无明显的统计学意义(P> 0.05);不同水平的医师在无辅助诊断工 具的情况下对结肠息肉检出情况比较差异 有明显的统计学意义(P<0.05);不同水 平的医师在使用辅助诊断工具的情况下对 结肠息肉检出情况比较差异无明显的统计 学意义(P>0.05);高年资水平的医师在 使用辅助诊断工具后,对结肠息肉的检出 率相对提高,但与不使用辅助诊断工具时 检出情况相比差异无明显的统计学意义(P >0.05)。结论 CT结肠成像诊断结肠息肉 评估受放射科医师的年资水平的影响很 大,通过采用CAD辅助诊断评估可以缩小 或消除由不同年资水平造成的诊断差异。

Objective To explore the use of colon CT imaging in the diagnosis of colon polyps radiologists to assess differences. Methods Collection in April 2013 to March 2015 period in our hospital between examination was highly suspected as colon polyps in 120 cases of patients with colon CT image data, by four different levels of radiologists in use and do not use the auxiliary diagnostic tool for reading, fiber colonoscopy as gold standard, at different levels of doctors in different cases of colon polyps detection sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive predictive value and negative predictive value. Results At the physician in the diagnosis of colon polyps detection under the condition of same comparison difference has no obvious statistical significance (P>0.05); Different levels of physicians in without auxiliary diagnostic tool for colon polyps detected situation is difference have significant statistical significance (P<0.05); Different levels of physicians in the use of auxiliary diagnostic tools of colon polyps detection under the condition of comparison difference has no obvious statistical significance (P>0.05); High qualification levels of physicians in the use of auxiliary diagnostic tools, relative improve detection rate of colon polyps, but with the auxiliary diagnostic tool is not used there was no obvious difference detection than statistical significance (P>0.05). Conclusion CT imaging in the diagnosis of colon colon polyps assessment greatly depends on the level of seniority of radiologists, by adopting CAD auxiliary diagnosis can reduce or eliminate differences.

【关键词】放射诊断;CT结肠成像;结肠息肉;诊断差异;计算机辅助检测

【中图分类号】R445.3;R574.62

【文献标识码】A

【DOI】10.3969/j.issn.1672-5131.2015.10.027

前言

所谓息肉,指的是从黏膜表面突出到肠腔的肉状病变,在为明确 病理性质前统称为息肉,结肠息肉是临床上比较常见的疾病,间断性 便血或大便表面带血为主要的临床表现,部分患者也可能有腹部闷胀 不适、隐痛或腹痛症状[1-2]。目前,纤维结肠镜检查被国内外学者公认 为诊断结肠息肉的金标准,然而具体的临床实践中,受结肠脾曲和结 肠肝曲的影响,操作起来比较困难,费时费力,且患者的疼痛情况也 比较明显[3-4]。近年来,临床上采用CT结肠成像对该病进行诊断越来 越普遍,其具有高敏感度、快速、无创等特点。但是,CT结肠成像诊 断受读片者的个体因素影响较大,诊断时容易产生误差,本文特对在 CT结肠成像诊断结肠息肉中放射科医师评估诊断的差异进行相关的探 索,以缩小或消除放射科医师评估诊断的差异。